Skip to main content

Differences Between a Trial by Written Declaration and a Trial by Jury

When contesting a traffic ticket in California, you have the option to choose between a trial by written declaration and a court trial (in-person). However, it's important to note that traffic violations typically do not involve jury trials. Here are the key differences between a trial by written declaration and a trial by jury:

Trial by Written Declaration​

1. Process:​

  • Written Submission: You submit a written statement and any supporting evidence to the court. The officer who issued the ticket also submits a written statement.
  • No Court Appearance: You do not need to appear in court. Everything is handled through written documents.
  • Judge's Decision: A judge reviews both written statements and the evidence, then makes a decision. The decision is mailed to you.

2. Requirements:​

  • Form TR-205: You must fill out and submit Form TR-205 (Request for Trial by Written Declaration).
  • Bail Payment: You are required to deposit the bail amount when you submit your request.
  • Evidence: You can attach photographs, diagrams, witness statements, and other relevant documents to support your case.

3. Outcome​

When a judge reviews the written statements and evidence in a Trial by Written Declaration, they apply specific legal standards to make an informed decision.

Preponderance of Evidence​

The judge will evaluate the evidence based on the preponderance of evidence standard, which means that the decision will be made in favor of the party whose evidence is more convincing and probable. This standard is less stringent than the "beyond a reasonable doubt" standard used in criminal cases but still requires that the evidence presented be credible and persuasive.

Clarity and Detail of Documentation​

Judges prioritize clear, detailed, and well-organized documentation. Your written statement should be concise, yet thorough, and include all relevant facts and evidence. Ensure that your documentation is easy to follow and that key points are clearly highlighted.

Timestamps and Chronology​

The chronology of events is crucial. Providing a clear timeline of what happened, including specific dates and times, can help the judge understand the sequence of events and make a more accurate decision.

Officer Compliance with Procedural Requirements​

The judge will also consider whether the officer who issued the ticket followed all necessary procedural requirements. If there are discrepancies or omissions in the officer's report, this could impact the validity of the ticket.

Witness Statements and Supporting Evidence​

Including witness statements and other supporting evidence, such as photographs or diagrams, can significantly strengthen your case. Ensure that all evidence is properly authenticated and clearly linked to your argument.

By understanding these legal standards and judicial considerations, you can structure your written declaration to present a strong, well-supported argument, increasing your chances of a favorable outcome.

Trial by Jury​

1. Process:​

  • In-Person Appearance: You must appear in court for the trial. This involves presenting your case in front of a judge and possibly a jury, depending on the type of case.
  • Jury Selection: In a jury trial, a group of citizens is selected to hear the case and determine the verdict. However, for traffic violations, a jury trial is generally not an option; these cases are typically bench trials (decided by a judge).

`---

Differences Between a Trial by Written Declaration and a Trial by Jury

When contesting a traffic ticket in California, you have the option to choose between a trial by written declaration and a court trial (in-person). However, it's important to note that traffic violations typically do not involve jury trials. Here are the key differences between a trial by written declaration and a court trial, including important financial considerations:

Trial by Written Declaration​

1. Process:​

  • Written Submission: You submit a written statement and any supporting evidence to the court. The officer who issued the ticket also submits a written statement.
  • No Court Appearance: You do not need to appear in court. Everything is handled through written documents.
  • Judge's Decision: A judge reviews both written statements and the evidence, then makes a decision. The decision is mailed to you.

2. Requirements:​

3. Outcome​

When a judge reviews the written statements and evidence in a Trial by Written Declaration, they apply specific legal standards to make an informed decision.

Preponderance of Evidence​

A judge evaluates the evidence based on the preponderance of evidence standard, meaning that the decision favors the party with the more convincing and probable evidence. This standard is less stringent than "beyond a reasonable doubt" but still requires credible and persuasive documentation.

Clarity and Detail of Documentation​

Judges prioritize clear and well-organized documentation. Your statement should be concise yet thorough, including all relevant facts and evidence, and should highlight key points effectively.

Timestamps and Chronology​

Providing a clear timeline of events, including specific dates and times, helps the judge understand the sequence of events and make a more accurate decision.

Officer Compliance with Procedural Requirements​

The judge considers whether the officer followed all necessary procedural requirements. Discrepancies in the officer's report may impact the validity of the ticket.

Witness Statements and Supporting Evidence​

Including authenticated witness statements and other supporting evidence, such as photographs or diagrams, can strengthen your case. Properly linking evidence to your argument is essential.

Trial by Jury​

1. Process:​

  • In-Person Appearance: You must appear in court for the trial, which involves presenting your case before a judge.
  • Jury Selection: In general cases, a jury is selected to hear the case and determine the verdict. However, for traffic violations, these cases are typically bench trials (decided by a judge).

2. Requirements:​

  • Court Procedures: You must adhere to judicial protocols, which include presenting evidence, calling witnesses, and cross-examining the officer who issued the ticket.
  • Legal Representation: You have the option to hire an attorney, which can improve your chances of success during the trial.

3. Cost-Benefit Analysis:​

  • Trial by Written Declaration:

    • Generally incurs lower overall costs, as the bail deposit is refundable upon a favorable decision.
    • There are no attorney fees, and it eliminates the need to take time off work, which reduces indirect expenses related to lost wages or transportation costs.

  • Court Trial:

    • May involve non-refundable bail deposits and potential attorney fees, significantly increasing the overall cost.
    • Attendance requires in-person hearings that could lead to additional expenses, such as travel costs and lost income due to time off work.

4. Outcome:​

  • Judge or Jury Decision: In a jury trial, the jury decides the verdict based on evidence. In a bench trial, the judge renders the decision.
  • Potential for Appeal: If you are found guilty, you may have the option to appeal the decision based on legal grounds.

Accessibility Considerations​

When choosing between a Trial by Written Declaration and a Court Trial, individuals with various needs, including those with disabilities and mental health conditions, should consider the following accessibility options to ensure a smooth and fair process:

Trial by Written DeclarationCourt Trial (Bench Trial)
Mobility Impairments: Highly accessible since it eliminates the need to travel to the courthouse.Physical Accessibility: Courthouses feature wheelchair ramps, elevators, and accessible restrooms.
Ease of Submission: Documents can be submitted electronically or by mail, accommodating individuals with transportation difficulties.Communication Aids: Courts provide sign language interpreters and assistive listening devices upon request.
Environmental Control: Submitters can prepare declarations in a comfortable setting, reducing stress.Service Animals: Individuals with disabilities may bring service animals into the courtroom.
Mental Health Considerations: A trial by written declaration can be less stressful for individuals with anxiety, PTSD, or other conditions, as it avoids in-person appearances.Flexible Scheduling: Courts may offer flexible scheduling for individuals needing additional support during the trial process.
Mental Health Accommodations: Courts may allow closed courtrooms to reduce public trial stress, offer break requests, and permit support persons to assist individuals during the trial.

By understanding and utilizing these accommodations, individuals with disabilities and mental health conditions can effectively navigate the trial process, whether opting for a Trial by Written Declaration or a Court Trial, ensuring their rights and needs are adequately addressed.

Summary​

  • Trial by Written Declaration: Involves submitting written statements and evidence without appearing in court. The judge reviews the documents and makes a decision, which is convenient and avoids court appearances but limits your ability to present oral testimony and cross-examine witnesses.
  • Trial by Jury: Typically not available for traffic violations; for other cases, it involves appearing in court, presenting evidence, and having a jury decide the verdict. This method allows for a more comprehensive presentation of your case but requires more time and effort.

For traffic violations, the more relevant comparison is between a trial by written declaration and a court trial (bench trial), as jury trials are not commonly used for such cases. To understand the key differences and potential pitfalls, refer to common mistakes to avoid when submitting the TR-205 and reasons your TR-205 might be rejected.`

3. Outcome:​

  • Judge or Jury Decision: In a jury trial, the jury decides the verdict based on the evidence presented. In a bench trial, the judge makes the decision.
  • Potential for Appeal: If you are found guilty, you may have the option to appeal the decision based on legal grounds.

Accessibility Considerations​

When choosing between a Trial by Written Declaration and a Court Trial, individuals with various needs, including those with disabilities and mental health conditions, should consider the following accessibility options to ensure a smooth and fair process:

Trial by Written DeclarationCourt Trial (Bench Trial)
Mobility Impairments: This option is highly accessible for those with limited mobility, as it eliminates the need to travel to the courthouse or attend in person.Physical Accessibility: Courthouses are equipped with features such as wheelchair ramps, elevators, and accessible restrooms to accommodate individuals with mobility impairments.
Ease of Submission: All documents and evidence can be submitted electronically or by mail, accommodating individuals who may have difficulties with transportation or require flexible submission methods.Communication Aids: Courts can provide sign language interpreters, assistive listening devices, and other necessary communication support upon request to ensure effective participation.
Environmental Control: Submitters can prepare their declarations in a comfortable and controlled environment, reducing the stress associated with traveling or navigating physical court spaces.Service Animals: Individuals with disabilities are permitted to bring service animals into the courtroom, ensuring they have the necessary support during the trial.
Mental Health Considerations: For individuals with anxiety, PTSD, or other mental health conditions, a trial by written declaration can be less stressful since it does not require in-person appearances or direct interactions with court personnel.Accessible Documentation: Courts can provide documents in alternative formats, such as large print or Braille, for those with visual impairments, ensuring all parties have equal access to information.
Flexible Scheduling: Courts may offer flexible scheduling or extended time for individuals who need additional support or accommodations during the trial process.
Mental Health Accommodations:
- Closed Courtroom: In some cases, individuals with severe anxiety or PTSD may request a closed courtroom to reduce the stress of a public trial.
- Additional Breaks: Courts can accommodate requests for more frequent breaks during the trial to help manage stress and anxiety.
- Support Persons: Individuals may be allowed to have a support person present during the trial, such as a therapist or family member, to provide emotional support.
- Pre-Trial Preparation: Courts can provide information and resources to help individuals prepare for the trial, including counseling services or stress management tips, to make the process less daunting.

By understanding and utilizing these accommodations, individuals with both physical disabilities and mental health conditions can effectively navigate the trial process, whether opting for a Trial by Written Declaration or a Court Trial, ensuring their rights and needs are adequately addressed.

Summary​

  • Trial by Written Declaration: Involves submitting written statements and evidence without appearing in court. The judge reviews the documents and makes a decision. This method is convenient and avoids court appearances but limits your ability to present oral testimony and cross-examine witnesses. For more information on the process, refer to how to contest a speeding ticket and what to include in a trial by written declaration.
  • Trial by Jury: Typically not available for traffic violations. For other cases, it involves appearing in court, presenting evidence, and having a jury decide the verdict. This method allows for a more comprehensive presentation of your case but requires more time and effort.

For traffic violations, the more relevant comparison is between a trial by written declaration and a court trial (bench trial), as jury trials are not commonly used for such cases. To understand the key differences and potential pitfalls, mistakes to avoid when filling the TR-205, and reasons for TR-205 to be rejected.