VA Dependency Claims and Appeals: Form 21-686c and Beyond

Dependency claims represent a critical expansion opportunity for veterans service organizations (VSOs), accredited claims agents, and benefits consultants operating in the veterans disability space. While initial disability ratings establish baseline compensation, dependency claims serve as high-value add-ons that can increase monthly payments by $150-$500+ per dependent, creating substantial retroactive liability when mishandled. The complexity of these claims—coupled with a 40%+ appeal rate on initial decisions—has transformed dependency appeals into a specialized practice area requiring sophisticated documentation strategies and lane selection expertise under the Appeals Modernization Act (AMA).

The financial stakes are significant. A veteran with a 70% disability rating receiving $1,716.28 monthly (2025 rates) gains an additional $134.00 for a spouse, $134.00 for the first child, and $65.00 for each additional child. For a veteran with three dependents, this represents $3,996 annually in additional compensation. When claims are denied or improperly adjudicated, retroactive awards can exceed $20,000 depending on the original claim date and appeal timeline.

VA Form 21-686c: Declaration of Dependents

VA Form 21-686c serves as the foundational document for establishing or modifying dependent status under 38 CFR § 3.4. This form operates as a dynamic record that must be updated within specific timeframes to preserve retroactive benefits and avoid overpayment debt.

When to File

Triggering Events Requiring Form 21-686c Submission:

• Marriage: Within 12 months to secure retroactive benefits to the marriage date
• Divorce: Immediately to prevent overpayment debt accumulation
• Birth/Adoption: Within 12 months for retroactive coverage
• Child aging out: At 18th birthday (or 23rd if school attendance ceases)
• School enrollment: When child turns 18 and continues full-time education
• Parent dependency: When veteran begins providing >50% financial support
• Death of dependent: Within 30 days to adjust benefits

Failure to file within the 12-month window results in benefits commencing from the date VA receives the form, not the qualifying event date, creating potential losses of $1,500-$6,000 in retroactive compensation.

Required Information by Dependent Type

Spouse Documentation:

• Certified marriage certificate (original or court-certified copy)
• Social Security numbers for both parties
• Date and location of marriage
• Previous marriage termination documentation (divorce decree or death certificate)
• Dependent children from previous marriages (if applicable)

Child Documentation (Under 18):

• Certified birth certificate or adoption decree
• Social Security number
• Custody documentation if veteran is non-custodial parent
• Stepchild: Marriage certificate proving veteran's marriage to biological parent

School-Age Children (18-23):

• VA Form 21-674 (Request for Approval of School Attendance)
• School certification of full-time enrollment (12+ credit hours)
• Accreditation verification of educational institution
• Last school term attendance documentation
• Expected graduation date

Dependent Parents:

• VA Form 21P-509 (Statement of Dependency of Parent(s))
• Detailed income statements for past 12 months
• Asset declarations excluding primary residence
• Proof of veteran providing >50% financial support
• Medical expense documentation if applicable

Supporting Documentation Requirements

The VA employs a Rules-Based Processing System (RBPS) that auto-adjudicates straightforward claims submitted through eBenefits without additional documentation. However, adding documentation triggers manual review, extending processing from 1-7 days to 30-90 days. Strategic practitioners submit only required documentation based on claim complexity:

For RBPS Auto-Processing:

• Submit Form 21-686c exclusively
• Ensure all Social Security numbers match VA records exactly
• Verify marriage/divorce dates align with official records
• Confirm no custody disputes or complex financial arrangements

For Manual Review (When Documentation is Mandatory):

• Common-law marriages: Affidavits, joint financial records, state recognition documents
• Stepchildren: Custody orders proving veteran's financial responsibility
• Adopted children: Final adoption decrees and amended birth certificates
• Dependent parents: Bank statements, receipts, and notarized affidavits of support

School Attendance Verification for Adult Children

VA Form 21-674 requires submission within 60 days of semester commencement and annual re-certification. The form captures critical data points:

Section I (Verification of School Attendance):

• School name, address, and accreditation status
• Course details including sessions per week and credit hours
• Enrollment verification by school official
• Federal tuition assistance disclosure (affects DEA benefits coordination)

Section II (Verification of Termination):

• Required within 30 days of school discontinuation
• School official certification of last attendance date
• Reason for termination (graduation, withdrawal, marriage)

Failure to submit Form 21-674 results in immediate suspension of dependent benefits and initiation of overpayment recovery proceedings.

Documentation for Different Dependent Types

Spouse: Marriage Certificate, Divorce Decrees, and Common-Law Considerations

Standard Marriage Documentation: Certified copies from county recorder's office are mandatory—photocopies or digital images trigger development requests that add 30-45 days to processing. The VA cross-references marriage dates against divorce decrees to ensure no overlap that would disqualify the claim.

Common-Law Marriage Complexities: Only 11 states recognize common-law marriages, and the veteran must prove:

• Mutual intent to marry
• Cohabitation for required statutory period (typically 7+ years)
• Public representation as married couple
• Joint financial documentation (tax returns, mortgages, insurance policies)

Strategic Filing Approach: Submit VA Form 21-686c through eBenefits for RBPS processing first. If denied, file Supplemental Claim with common-law affidavits, joint lease agreements, and witness statements. This two-stage approach preserves the earliest possible effective date while building an evidence record for appeal.

Children: Birth Certificates and Adoption Records

Biological Children: Long-form birth certificates listing both parents are preferred. Short-form certificates may trigger requests for additional documentation. For children born during marriage, paternity is presumed. For children born outside marriage, acknowledgment of paternity or court order is required.

Adopted Children: Final adoption decrees must be court-certified and include:

• Date adoption was finalized
• Legal names post-adoption
• State court seal and judge signature
• Termination of prior parental rights documentation

Special Consideration for Children with Disabilities: Seriously disabled adult children (disability acquired before age 18) require:

• Medical evidence establishing permanent incapacity
• Physician certification of inability to self-support
• Prior dependency establishment before age 18
• Annual re-certification of continuing disability

Stepchildren: Marriage and Custody Documentation

Stepchild dependency requires proving the veteran is the "parent" for VA purposes, which demands:

• Marriage certificate to biological parent
• Evidence child resides with veteran OR veteran provides >50% financial support
• Custody documentation if biological parent is non-custodial
• Adoption of stepchild (if applicable)

Critical Timeline: Stepchild benefits terminate when the veteran's marriage to the biological parent ends through divorce, regardless of continuing financial support or established relationship.

Dependent Parents: Income and Dependency Evidence

Parent dependency claims face the highest denial rate (approximately 47%) due to stringent financial thresholds. The VA evaluates:

Income Thresholds (2025):

• Single parent: Net income below $400/month after allowable expenses
• Two parents: Combined net income below $660/month
• Asset limits excluding non-countable resources (primary residence, vehicle)

Documentation Requirements:

• VA Form 21P-509 with 12-month income/expense history
• Bank statements showing veteran's contributions
• Cancelled checks or electronic transfer records
• Medical expense receipts reducing net income
• Notarized affidavit of support from veteran

Strategic Evidence Submission: Organize documentation chronologically with summary spreadsheet showing monthly veteran contributions exceeding 50% of parent's essential expenses. Include comparative bank statements demonstrating the veteran's account funding parent's living costs.

Appeals Process Overview

The Appeals Modernization Act (AMA) created a three-lane system effective February 19, 2019, that fundamentally changed dependency appeal strategy. Veterans must select one lane per issue and cannot simultaneously pursue multiple review paths for the same issue.

Supplemental Claim (New Evidence Path)

VA Form 20-0995 allows submission of new and relevant evidence not previously considered. This lane preserves the original effective date if filed within one year of the decision being appealed.

Key Characteristics:

• New evidence must be "relevant" to the specific issue on appeal
• VA has duty to assist in developing evidence
• Average processing time: 65-127 days
• Success rate: 45-55% for dependency claims with proper documentation

Strategic Use Cases:

• Initial claim lacked critical documentation (marriage certificate, school verification)
• New medical evidence for disabled adult child claims
• Correction of administrative errors in dependency determination

Higher-Level Review (Same Evidence, New Review)

VA Form 20-0996 provides de novo review by a senior adjudicator who can identify Clear and Unmistakable Error (CUE) in the original decision.

Key Characteristics:

• No new evidence permitted (evidence of record only)
• Informal conference option available (telephone discussion with reviewer)
• Review based on original evidence and applicable law
• Processing time target: 125 days
• Success rate: 30-40% when CUE is properly identified

Strategic Use Cases:

• Legal error in dependency eligibility determination
• Misapplication of regulatory criteria for parent dependency
• Procedural violations (inadequate notice, failure to assist)

Board Appeal (BVA Review Options)

VA Form 10182 (Notice of Disagreement) initiates review by a Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans' Appeals. The Board offers three docket options:

Direct Review Docket:

• Veterans Law Judge reviews existing record only
• No new evidence, no hearing
• Fastest Board option: 551 days average (FY 2024)
• Best for clear legal errors or when no additional evidence exists

Evidence Submission Docket:

• Submit new evidence within 90 days of filing NOD
• No hearing requested
• Average processing: 675 days
• Ideal when documentation exists but wasn't submitted originally

Hearing Docket:

• Request hearing before Veterans Law Judge (in-person, video, or virtual)
• Can submit evidence up to 90 days before hearing
• Longest wait time: 750 days average
• Appropriate for complex factual disputes requiring testimony

Choosing the Right Appeal Lane

Decision Tree for Dependency Appeals:

If new evidence exists (marriage certificate, school verification, financial records): → Supplemental Claim (Form 20-0995) for fastest resolution and effective date preservation

If no new evidence but clear legal error (misapplied regulation, incorrect income calculation): → Higher-Level Review (Form 20-0996) with informal conference request

If complex factual dispute (common-law marriage validity, parent dependency percentage): → Board Appeal (Form 10182) with Evidence Submission docket

If immediate resolution critical and no new evidence: → Higher-Level Review (faster than Board, preserves appeal rights)

If case involves multiple issues with different evidence postures: → File separate appeals using different lanes per issue

Supplemental Claim Documentation

VA Form 20-0995 Structure

The Supplemental Claim form requires precise identification of issues and evidence organization:

Part I: Veteran Identification

• Name, file number, contact information
• Benefit type (compensation, pension, DIC)
• Signature and certification

Part II: Issues for Supplemental Claim

• Specific issue(s) being appealed (e.g., "Denial of spouse dependency")
• Date of prior VA decision
• Area of disagreement (eligibility, effective date)

Part III: New and Relevant Evidence

• List of evidence being submitted
• Description of how evidence relates to the issue
• Request for VA assistance in obtaining records (if applicable)

New and Relevant Evidence Requirements

"New" Evidence Definition: Information not previously part of the claims file. This includes:

• Recently obtained marriage certificates
• Updated school attendance verification (Form 21-674)
• Revised financial documentation for parent claims
• Corrected birth certificates

"Relevant" Evidence Standard: Evidence that tends to prove or disprove a material fact in dispute. For dependency claims, relevance is straightforward—documentation establishing the legal relationship or financial dependency directly addresses eligibility criteria.

Strategic Evidence Packaging: Organize evidence in chronological order with cover letter indexing each document to specific eligibility criteria. For example:

Document	Criterion Addressed	Regulatory Basis
Certified marriage certificate	Legal spouse status	38 CFR § 3.50
Joint tax returns (3 years)	Financial interdependence	38 CFR § 3.804
Birth certificate of child	Biological relationship	38 CFR § 3.57

Timeline and Effective Date Preservation

One-Year Rule: Supplemental Claims filed within one year of the decision being appealed preserve the original claim's effective date. This is critical for dependency claims where retroactive benefits can exceed $10,000.

Evidence Submission Timeline:

• File Form 20-0995 within one year of decision
• Submit evidence with form or within 30 days of filing
• VA may request additional evidence within 60 days
• Decision typically issued within 90-127 days

Strategic Timing: File Supplemental Claims immediately upon receiving missing documentation. Do not wait for perfect evidence package—file with what is available and supplement within the development period. This secures the earliest possible effective date while allowing evidence refinement.

Higher-Level Review Process

VA Form 20-0996 Structure

The Higher-Level Review request requires identifying specific issues without submitting new evidence:

Part I: Personal Information

• Veteran identification and contact details
• Benefit type and file number

Part II: Higher-Level Review Options

• Same office or different office request
• Informal conference election (highly recommended)

Part III: Issues for Review

• Precise identification of each issue
• Date of prior VA decision
• Specific error alleged (factual, legal, procedural)

Identifying Clear and Unmistakable Error (CUE)

CUE in dependency claims typically involves:

• Incorrect legal standard applied: Using obsolete income thresholds for parent dependency
• Failure to consider evidence: Overlooking submitted marriage certificate
• Misinterpretation of regulation: Incorrectly calculating >50% support requirement
• Procedural violation: Inadequate notice of evidence requirements

CUE Allegation Framework: "The prior decision committed clear and unmistakable error by [specific error], which, if not made, would have manifestly changed the outcome. The correct application of [regulation] with the evidence of record required approval of dependency."

Informal Conference Strategies

The informal conference represents a unique opportunity for direct advocacy:

Preparation:

• Review complete claims file before conference
• Prepare concise summary of error(s) identified
• Anticipate counterarguments and prepare responses
• Have regulatory citations readily available

During Conference:

• State the specific error clearly within first 2 minutes
• Reference exact evidence of record supporting position
• Ask clarifying questions if reviewer expresses skepticism
• Request written summary of conference discussion

Post-Conference:

• Document conference date, time, and reviewer name
• Note any commitments or observations made by reviewer
• Prepare supplemental written argument if permitted

Technology for Efficient Claims Processing

Managing High-Volume Dependency Claims

Cloud-based case management systems enable VSOs and claims agents to track multiple dependency claims across various processing stages:

• Centralized deadline tracking for 12-month filing windows
• Automated reminders for school attendance re-certifications
• Document checklists by dependent type
• Appeal lane selection decision support

AI-Powered Form Filling

Advanced form-filling automation can extract veteran data from existing claims records and auto-populate Form 21-686c, Form 21-674, and appeals forms. For service providers managing large veteran client portfolios, AI form-filling reduces manual data entry while ensuring consistency across related forms. These systems can pre-populate spouse, child, and parent information from prior submissions, reducing processing time and transcription errors.

---

Dependency claims and appeals represent a significant practice area for veterans service providers, combining high-value financial outcomes with complex documentation requirements. VSOs and claims agents who master the Appeals Modernization Act's lane selection strategy, understand the specific documentation requirements for each dependent type, and implement systematic quality control processes deliver measurable value to veteran clients while building sustainable practice operations.